Sellm

BrightEdge vs Otterly AI: Which AI Overview Tracking Tool Wins in 2025?

The AI search revolution isn't coming, it's already here. With Google AI Overviews now appearing for millions of queries and ChatGPT becoming a go-to research tool, brands face a critical question: How do you track and optimize your presence in this new landscape?

Two platforms have emerged as popular choices for AI Overview monitoring: BrightEdge, the SEO industry veteran expanding into AI tracking, and Otterly AI, the specialized newcomer built specifically for this challenge. But which one actually delivers the insights you need to stay competitive?

After extensive testing and analysis, here's what we discovered about both platforms, including why neither might be your best choice.

BrightEdge: The Comprehensive GEO Solution

BrightEdge has been a heavyweight in enterprise SEO for over a decade, and their expansion into AI Overview tracking feels like a natural evolution. Built on their DataCube technology, their AI monitoring capabilities integrate seamlessly with their existing SEO infrastructure.

What sets BrightEdge apart is their enterprise-first approach. This isn't a startup scrambling to build features, but rather an established platform methodically extending their reach into generative search optimization. Their AI Overview tracking sits within a broader ecosystem of content intelligence, competitive analysis, and performance measurement tools.

The platform excels at large-scale data processing. If you're monitoring thousands of keywords across multiple brands, BrightEdge's infrastructure can handle the load without breaking a sweat. Their AI Overview detection algorithms are sophisticated, catching nuanced variations in how AI summaries appear across different query types and geographic regions.

Otterly.AI: The Focused Brand Monitor

Otterly AI represents the opposite philosophy: laser focus over breadth. Founded in 2024 by a team that saw the AI search shift coming, they've built their entire platform around one core mission of helping brands understand and optimize their presence in AI-generated responses.

This singular focus shows in their user experience. Where BrightEdge requires navigation through multiple modules and dashboards, Otterly AI puts AI search monitoring front and center. Their onboarding process gets you tracking brand mentions across ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google AI Overviews within minutes, not hours.

The platform shines in conversational keyword discovery, identifying the specific prompts and questions your audience actually uses when talking to AI systems. This isn't traditional keyword research; it's prompt intelligence that reveals how people naturally ask about your industry when they're not constrained by search box thinking.

Pros: Where Each Tool Shines

BrightEdge Pros:

  • Enterprise Infrastructure: Built to handle massive data volumes with reliable uptime and performance that enterprise teams demand
  • Integrated Workflow: AI Overview tracking connects directly with content optimization, competitive analysis, and reporting tools you're already using
  • Advanced Attribution: Sophisticated tracking of how AI Overview appearances impact organic traffic and conversions
  • Historical Data Depth: Years of SEO data provide context for understanding AI search trends and correlations
  • Account Management: Dedicated support teams and strategic consultation for complex implementations
  • Compliance Ready: Enterprise-grade security and data handling for regulated industries

Otterly.AI Pros:

  • Platform Coverage: Monitors more AI platforms than most competitors, including Copilot, Gemini, and emerging AI search engines
  • Rapid Setup: Get meaningful insights within your first hour of use with no lengthy onboarding or training required
  • Conversational Intelligence: Excels at identifying natural language patterns and user intent in AI conversations
  • Real-time Alerts: Instant notifications when your brand appears or disappears from AI responses
  • Affordable Entry Point: Pricing that makes AI search monitoring accessible to smaller businesses and agencies
  • Innovation Velocity: New features and platform integrations roll out rapidly compared to enterprise competitors

Cons: Where They Fall Short

BrightEdge Cons:

  • Overwhelming Complexity: The platform's depth becomes a liability for teams that just need AI Overview tracking without enterprise SEO features
  • Slow Feature Development: Enterprise development cycles mean new AI platforms and features take months to integrate
  • Price Barrier: Custom enterprise pricing often starts in five figures annually, pricing out mid-market companies
  • Setup Complexity: Meaningful implementation requires weeks of configuration and training
  • Limited AI Platform Coverage: Focuses heavily on Google AI Overviews while giving less attention to ChatGPT, Perplexity, and other platforms
  • Rigid Reporting: Customizing dashboards and reports requires technical expertise or professional services

Otterly.AI Cons:

  • Feature Gaps: Missing advanced analytics like cohort analysis, attribution modeling, and statistical significance testing
  • Limited Historical Data: Being new means less baseline data for trend analysis and competitive benchmarking
  • Integration Challenges: Fewer third-party integrations compared to established platforms, requiring manual data export
  • Scalability Questions: Unclear how the platform performs when monitoring thousands of keywords across multiple brands
  • Support Limitations: Smaller team means longer response times and less specialized consultation
  • Data Export Restrictions: Basic plans limit how much historical data you can extract for your own analysis

Pricing: Breaking Down the Investment

BrightEdge Pricing:

BrightEdge operates on custom enterprise pricing, which means "if you have to ask, you probably can't afford it." Based on industry reports and user feedback, annual contracts typically start around $30,000 for basic implementations and can exceed $100,000 for comprehensive deployments with multiple modules and extensive keyword tracking.

The pricing model includes platform access, data processing, and account management, but additional features like advanced AI analytics or expanded geographic coverage often carry premium charges. Implementation services and training typically add 20-30% to the base cost.

For enterprise teams with substantial budgets and complex needs, this investment can deliver strong ROI through improved content performance and competitive intelligence. For everyone else, it's a non-starter.

Otterly.AI Pricing:

Otterly AI's transparent pricing starts at $29/month for basic AI search monitoring, scaling up to $149/month for their professional tier with advanced features and higher usage limits. Enterprise customers can access custom pricing for volume discounts and additional integrations.

The entry-level plan includes monitoring for up to 10 keywords across major AI platforms, basic sentiment analysis, and email alerts. Professional plans expand keyword limits, add team collaboration features, and provide more granular analytics.

What's refreshing is their 14-day free trial with full feature access and no credit card required. This lets you properly evaluate the platform before committing, something BrightEdge doesn't offer.

The Alternative: Sellm

After testing both platforms extensively, we kept asking ourselves: Is there a better way to approach AI Overview tracking? That's where Sellm enters the conversation.

Sellm bridges the gap between BrightEdge's enterprise complexity and Otterly AI's feature limitations. Built specifically for AI visibility tracking, Sellm combines comprehensive platform coverage with the analytical depth that serious marketers need.

What makes Sellm different:

  • Balanced Approach: Enterprise-grade analytics without enterprise-grade complexity or pricing
  • Comprehensive Coverage: Tracks Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, and emerging AI platforms from a single dashboard
  • Competitive Intelligence: Advanced competitor benchmarking that reveals exactly how your rivals are winning in AI search
  • Actionable Optimization: Specific recommendations for improving your AI search visibility, not just monitoring data
  • Flexible Pricing: Scalable plans that work for agencies, mid-market companies, and enterprise teams
  • Fast Implementation: Get meaningful insights within days, not weeks or months

Where BrightEdge overwhelms and Otterly AI underwhelms, Sellm hits the sweet spot of powerful functionality with practical usability.

Summary: Making the Right GEO Tool Choice for Your Business

Your ideal AI Overview tracking solution depends on your specific situation:

Choose BrightEdge if: You're a large enterprise with complex SEO needs, substantial budget, and existing BrightEdge infrastructure. The platform makes sense when AI Overview tracking is part of a broader content intelligence strategy, and you have the resources to handle its complexity.

Choose Otterly AI if: You're a smaller business or agency that needs basic AI search monitoring without enterprise features. It's perfect for getting started with AI Overview tracking when budget constraints make other options unrealistic.

Choose Sellm if: You want the best of both worlds with comprehensive AI monitoring and enterprise-quality insights at a reasonable price point. It's ideal for growing businesses, agencies, and enterprise teams that need powerful functionality without unnecessary complexity.

The AI search landscape is evolving rapidly, and the tools you choose today will shape your competitive position tomorrow. While both BrightEdge and Otterly AI have their merits, the future belongs to platforms that can deliver comprehensive insights without overwhelming complexity or prohibitive costs.

That's exactly what Sellm was built to provide, and why it's becoming the preferred choice for smart marketers navigating the AI search revolution.